Contributors

Saturday, September 20, 2008

What makes Australian Literature Australian?

Here are just some thoughts as part of the discussion on WHAT MAKES AUSTRALIAN LITERATURE AUSTRALIAN as part of the Brisbane Writers’ Festival panel sponsored by AustLit: the resource for Australian Literature

Having this discussion is about as hard as the one about determining what Australian identity is – because there is no hard and fast definition.

I’m wearing three hats as I write this (which may explain why I have a chronic headache!): one hat belongs to the Chair of the ASA, one belongs to the editor of the Macquarie PEN Anthology of Aboriginal Literature, and another belongs to Anita Heiss the author. And so, I’d like to share ideas from all positions as part of this discussion.

As Chair of the ASA – I represent the professional association for Australia's literary creators. The organisation was formed in 1963 to promote and protect the rights of Australia's writers and illustrators, and now has almost 3000 members across Australia. Our members are biographers, illustrators, academics, historians, cartoonists, scientists, food and wine writers, children’s writers, ghost writers, librettists, travel writers, romance writers, translators, computer programmers, journalists, poets and novelists.

The ASA has a very open view of what constitutes Australian literature, and the most recent debate we have had within the organisation was around setting the criteria for the Barbara Jefferis award which is offered annually for “the best novel written by an Australian author that depicts women and girls in a positive way or otherwise empowers the status of women and girls in society”. Essentially, we decided that an ‘Australian author’ is someone who is an Australian citizen or permanent resident. And being an Australian author would therefore constitute them producing Australian literature.

Because we represent such a diverse membership I emailed some members in preparation for this discussion to get their perspective on the topic:

Alex Miller – twice winner of the Miles Franklin said. He wrote this in CAPS so I think he was shouting at me...

"DEFINITIONS OF THE AUSTRALIANNESS OF AUSTRALIAN WRITING WILL ONLY SERVE TO CONFIRM THE STEREOTYPES AND WILL NEVER INCLUDE THE UNEXPECTED. WE DON’T NEED A DEFINITION OF IT; WE NEED TO LEARN TO CELEBRATE IT.

Anyone who believes we need a definition of something indefinable is not an artist, but publicist.”

Pamela Freeman – award- winning author of 17 books, including fantasy, said:

“Australian literature is not necessarily set in Australia or explicitly about Australia or Australians, but it reflects upon, explores, celebrates or grieves over human experience through stories which are informed and influenced by deep and long-lasting experience of Australian culture, geography, landscape and climate.

Is that inclusive enough for you? It would exclude, for example, DH Lawrence's Kangaroo, since his experience was neither deep nor long-lasting, but would include the children's books of Odo Hirsch, although many of them appear to be set in Europe.
I would argue, for example, that Australian writers of fantasy are exploring themes and issues quite differently from US fantasy writers, even those of us who set our secondary creations in Northern Hemisphere landscapes.”

Multiple award-winning and internationally published children’s book author Libby Gleeson said:
“I'd argue it's as diverse as Australia itself - i.e. 'Not Meeting Mr Right' (chicklit) right through to Alex Miller (literary fiction) and spy stories and crime novels. I don't think there is a distinctive defining characteristic. I used to think Oz kids’ books were freer of limitation and censorship than those from Britain and America but you can't generalise about that even any more. And we don't see what comes out of Europe.”

Rosie Scott: novelist, essayist and playwright said:
“It's a very hard thing to define. In the early days it was easy - the defining characteristic of Australian literature was that it was usually about the bush, the outback and battlers. Now it's so varied and cosmopolitan, it borrows from so many cultures and literary traditions that the only defining characteristic I can think of that's particularly Australian is a certain irreverence, a lightness of touch in that most writers don't take themselves seriously, a lack of pomposity - but of course there are Australian writers who break that rule too!”

And from Jeremy Fisher who is the Executive Director of the ASA, but also a writer:
“Our literature isn't just fiction, nor, as Shaun Tan has demonstrated is
it just words. Our literature is our expression, in a myriad of forms, of
our own uniqueness.”

In further considering the issue of what makes Australian literature Australian, let’s turn the question around. Let's pretend we are American. What is American literature? Well, that's fairly obvious isn't it?

The problem for us is it's not obvious because our literature doesn't have the full authority of being ours because we read both American and British literature as well as our own. But by and large we very rarely read New Zealand literature. We might still be ANZACS but we don't read their books and that's largely to do with the colonial distribution agreements that still govern global publishing. These agreements have shaped the way we consider literature in general.

In NSW, the Board of Studies recently amended its K-12 syllabus to include an Australian literature component. This week as we have heard already, the English Teachers Association of NSW objected, saying that this was too prescriptive. Let me say that the changes still only meant that one-third of the material studies in English in NSW schools was Australian. Turn that around again and think of an American school -- how much material wouldn't be American? 0% or 1% Let's be generous and say 5%. [This might also explain why the American understanding of the rest of the world is missing!]

To be fair, the ETA argued it was wrong to concentrate on one medium - the book as text. But this argument shows how little they know about Australian literature. No oral traditions for a start. No performance poetry. No graphic novels. Shaun Tan? Sorry, NSW English teachers don't think you’re Australian literature. Margaret Wild and Julie Vivas, get out of NSW schools, you're not Australian literature! The teachers have said so. Isn't that absurd?

I’d like to switch hats quickly if I may, and in doing so wanted to flag that I am never categorised as an Australian author. I am always called and Aboriginal author – although all my work is about, reflects, and is based in Australia. In fact, when I released my first chick lit novel last year, I was told by one reviewer that I had created a new genre altogether, that of Koori chick-lit. Pioneering a new genre is exciting, but not when you are potentially excluded from the mainstream literary culture and discourse.

At other times I have had publishers tell me that my work isn’t really Aboriginal literature because it doesn’t fit their prescriptions of what Aboriginal literature is or should be – that is, it must be about ‘our issues’ of land rights, native title, racism and so on.

With that sense of ridiculous boxing of Aboriginal literature in mind, Peter Minter and I were very conscious of how we defined Aboriginal literature when we were putting together the Macquarie PEN Anthology of Aboriginal Literature which is the teaser to the 2009 release of the Macquarie PEN Anthology of Australian Literature.

We have always been told, ‘you’ve only ever had an oral literary tradition’, when in fact, what we’ve had is a storytelling tradition that included songs, dance painting (on rocks, on bodies on instruments, in the sand and so on) and yes, we have oral stories as well.

So when Peter and I were reading the 1000s of pages of material for potential inclusion in the anthology, we considered any written material that told our stories – as literature. And in a sense it freed us up from the often limited view of ‘literature’ in the mainstream arena. In our anthology we include Aboriginal literature as material created by Aboriginal writers, regardless of the genre, the content of the work or the style and voice of the writing.

Our definition is so broad that the Macquarie PEN Anthology of Aboriginal Literature includes a diverse collection of written works by Aboriginal people across a broad spectrum of styles and forms – like journalism, letters, petitions, poetry, prose – novels and short-stories, songs, plays, children’s books and social commentary.

The works chronicled in our anthology demonstrate the ongoing suffering of dispossession in Australia, but also the resilience of Aboriginal people across the country, and the hope and joy in our lives. And what these stories do is tell the history of the evolution of Aboriginal literature written in the English language. And the works range from Bennelong’s Letter to Lord Sydney’s Steward in 1796 right through to Alexis Wrights Carpentaria in 2007.

Our writing is about the First Australians and our life in Australia. And it is ‘Australian literature’.


[Acknowledgement to Dr Jeremy Fisher for assistance with ETA facts and figures]

16 comments:

admincrazy said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Pirra said...

Much food for thought there.

A whole new genre...hmm, yes. It's nice to be recognised as something fresh, new and unique but it can also be kind of lonely out there on your own.

I think as Australians we are lucky when it comes the range and depth of our literature. Because our society is so multicultural our voices can range from Indigenous, to Asian, to Mediterranean, to British, to European, to Middle Eastern and back again. Which only serves to make the defining and distinction if it that much more difficult to do.

But how nice is it to walk into a book store and see all those differently flavoured voices placed together on a single shelf simply titled "Australian Literature".

Dr Anita Heiss said...

I agree Pirra - great to have such wonderful and diverse stories and styles under the title 'Australian literature'. Peace, Anita

POKERVITA said...

Kerahasiaan Anda Terjamin
100% Terpercaya,Dan Tidak Diragukan Lagi.
Karena sudah Lebih Dari Ribuan Member kami Yang sudah Membuktikan nya...

Sekarang Giliran Anda yang Harus Membuktikan nya.
HOT PROMO DARI P0KERV1TA untuk para member kami :
* B0nus Referral 20% Seumur Hidup
* Bonus Hariaan Hingga 3juta
* Bonus Bulanan Hadiah Spesial untuk member yang bermain selama 1 bulan penuh
* Bonus Turn0ver 0,5%
* NO ROBOT & ADMIN
* 100% Fair Play Member Vs Member
* Proses Withdraw & Deposit Tercepat
* Customer Service yang baik dan ramah
Agen Poker Terpercaya
BONUS CASHBACK

Contact Us Person :
? LIVECHAT P`O`K`E`R`V`1`T`A
? WA: 082312256064
? BBM : D88B0154

Dylan Eales said...

Students can reach out to us with their queries at any point of the day or night and get the most effective solutions for them. Our best online assignment Australia talk about how to select and evaluate the right academic sources, which will help you clear all your assignment-related doubts at best and affordable price. Whenever need to search for Assignment help Adelaide, our experts will be assist you.

TutorVersal - Assignment Help said...

Thank you for your valuable information. It's highly appreciated. Though, I would like to suggest an online Homework Help provider that has assisted thousands of students globally for over 10 years now. Tutorversal is a professional academic assignment helper that has its headquarters in Melbourne, Australia. The writers associated with TutorVersal are Ph.D. holders from renowned universities and have in-depth subject knowledge. They understand each and every university requirement and, therefore, offer various services like case study writing help, report writing help, essay writing help, and overall homework help. I highly recommended their academic writing services as they have never let any student down and they even guide students to understand each and every concept.

Online Assignment Expert said...

For nursing students, it gets a bit difficult to even make time to content an online assignment help providing company for nursing assignment help. Which is why, we, at Online Assignment Expert have extended our assignment help services which only exist in order to make it more convenient for the nursing students to fetch assignment solutions from an online assignment help company. Therefore, in order to avail our nursing assignment help offering no plagiarism, Free Turnitin, Partial Payment, Unlimited Revisions, etc. You can contact our team of highly professional, experienced, PhD experts to avail the discounted services!

Daniel Steve said...

Students are given assignments, such as an essay, on a regular or periodic basis by their professors. These are mandatory and students are graded on the basis of the quality of work done by them. Essay writing may be a great opportunity to score the top grades but they come along with challenges as well. To overcome them, the best way is to consult an online academic helper who provides essay help. TutorVersal has a dedicated team of qualified essay and homework help experts who assist students with their assignment tasks. This not allows students to submit their work on time but also lets them score excellent grades in them!

FirstAssignmentHelp said...

A lot of valuable information can be derived from the post. Certainly, this compelling post will encourage readers to choose Assignment Help Australia services. You can email us at info@firstassignmenthelp.com.

Lauren Ann said...

Thank you for your informative content. I really appreciate it. However, I would like to recommend every single student that is facing any kind of challenges in their academic assignment, about highly accurate assignment writing services that are being offered by Industry best assignment help provider My Assignment Help Oz.
I could recall an event where I once urgently needed professional assignment writing service to help me make a perfectly structured essay in 2hours. This is when the best assignment writing services offered me a chance to avail their professional services and in a couple of days, I was rewarded with a huge round of applause for preparing the best assignment in front of the whole batch.

Unknown said...

I looked everywhere for completing my thesis but didn't receive satisfaction until I found Australian writing service and find all my doubts clear

Maria Garcia said...

Hey, great article you have there. I am sure that the students looking for assignment helpand ways to write their assignment got to learn a lot of things that were not clear before. The students who need guidance on how to write an assignment, I am also an academic expert who provide online assignment help to the university going students in their academic tasks at My Assignment Services. We are a team of professional experts who are all either a Master’s degree holder or a PhD scholar. For years, we have aided students who are busy in their part time jobs or cannot take out sufficient time for assignment writing. Their can you do my assignment questions are successfully addressed at My Assignment Services.

Unknown said...

A special thanks to Assignment Help Australia for providing an exceptional assignment within a short period of time. Your work is really amazing. Hope you reach heights in the future. You can email us at cs@Myassignmenthelpau.Com or Phone Number: +61-2-8005-8227

Williams Pater said...

Hello everyone i Am williams pater and i am from USA i am here to give my testimony about an herbal doctor called Dr,olu I was heartbroken because i had very small penis,not nice to satisfy a woman, i have been in so many relationship, but cut off because of my situation, i have used so many product which doctors prescribe for me, but could not offer me the help i searched for. i saw some few comments on the internet about this specialist called Dr,OLU and decided to email him on his email i saw on the internet,(drolusolutionhome@gmail.com ) so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal product for Penis Enlargement, Within three weeks of me use it, i began to feel the enlargement, " and now it just 4 weeks of using his products my penis is about 8 inches longer, and i had to settle thing out with my ex girlfriend , i was surprised when she said that she is satisfied with my performance in bed and i now have a large penis.thanks to DR OLU for is herbal product. you can also reach him with emsil drolusolutionhome@gmail.com though is..number WHATASPP him today on this number [ +2348140654426 ]

Unknown said...

Outstanding article! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. Your views are much like my own concerning this subject. I will visit daily your blog because I know. It may be very beneficial for me. My Assignment help

Dylan Eales said...

Sample Assignment bestows over the college going students with online assignment help. It is a consultancy possessing academic experts providing a number of subject-specific assignment helps. Marketing assignment help, economics assignment help, MATLAB assignment Help, MySQL assignment help, management assignment help, etc. are a few to name. The assignment help packages that they supply the students with ensure the students receive an HD or a full money back. With their assignment consultation services, the students can learn by exposing themselves to out-of-the-box learning when it comes to module related studies. For the quality of the in-depth research that is conducted before the experts at Sample Assignment lay their hands on a specific assignment, the prices are kept very close to the ground while the company has its head touching the sky. They offer services in Essays, CDRs, Resumes, Thesis, Research Proposals, Research Papers, Dissertations, etc. Be it any of the above, they provide ready to study from assignment solutions to the students who work-save in order to pay for the service and the online assignment services provider works on the motive of giving out value for every coin a particular student pays for the online assignment help Australia. With their Partial Payment and the optional feature of Countless Revisions, they have earned themselves two consecutive years of recognition.